The union representing 5,000 nurses, doctors, and other healthcare workers at Jackson Health System in Miami has asked a state grand jury to investigate alleged mismanagement that union officials say has the public hospital on the brink of financial ruin.
"It's time we know the truth about what's going on with Jackson's finances," Martha Baker, RN, president of SEIU Local 1991, said in a media release. "We owe it to the patients we serve and to the taxpayers who are funding Jackson."
Baker requested the grand jury investigation on Thursday in a hand-delivered letter to Katherine Fernandez-Rundle, the Miami-Dade state attorney.
JHS President/CEO Eneida Roldan, MD, said the union's allegations "are without merit and inaccurate," and that any information about the health system's operations is already open and available in the public domain.
"This is not the time for finger pointing or to cast blame," Roldan said in a media release. "No one person or factor is responsible for Jackson's woes and focusing on blame will get us no closer to a solution. Instead, we must all work together to address Jackson's challenges and to ensure its survival for years to come."
Florida law allows state attorneys to initiate grand jury investigations of public agencies and the public officials who run them. Grand juries can then report findings and recommendations concerning mismanagement, misconduct, or misuse of public funds.
Fernandez Rundle confirmed in a media release that her office had received the request. She said such requests are not uncommon "when concerned citizens feel that parts of their government are functioning poorly."
The Miami-Dade state attorney's spokesperson, Terry Chavez, says it would be "absolutely inaccurate at this point" to call the inquiry a criminal investigation.
"We get these requests all the time. It will be up to the grand jury to decide whether or not they choose to investigate what the union is requesting," she says. Chavez says the investigation request will be acted upon when a new 21-member grand jury begins its six-month term in May.
Baker cited media reports that Jackson executives recently surprised its own governing board by announcing that losses last year were $203 million instead of the $45 million that they initially reported. Jackson executives predicted that losses for the current fiscal year, which ends this September, mushroomed to $229 million from previous estimates of $87 million. Jackson also announced this week that it would begin cost-cutting measures that included laying off 20 union members.
"The only way for us to really find out the true extent of Jackson's mismanagement and current financial problems is for the state attorney's office to follow the money and find out who knew what, and when," Baker said.
Spend enough time in a doctor's office—either as an employee or a patient—and you're going to encounter conflict and tension.
For patients, already anxious about their health, even during well visits, it can be particularly unsettling to hear voices raised or accusations flying. It may be a receptionist dealing with a patient who has just been informed that his copay was raised. It could be an office manager confronting a billing clerk over a documentation error. It could be a physician assistant's personal troubles spilling into the work place.
Whatever the reason, conflict is a cancer in the healing environment. It has to be contained.
For years, Terri Levine, president of North Wales, PA—based Comprehensive Coaching U, has parachuted into stressed out physicians' offices to negotiate an end to hostilities.
"I've never seen a business, a corporation, a physician office, that doesn't have conflict," Levine says. "People are people. There is conflict in our experience. It's part of humanity." By far, she says, the most prevalent form of conflict is among coworkers.
Because of the serious nature of the work in physician offices, even on the best of workdays, stress—the seed corn for conflict—will always be present.
"There is more stress that we find particularly in medical doctor practices than in any others," Levine says. "In a retail store, you mess up, you don't ring up the right order. In a physician's office, you can be dealing with serious life-and-death issues. And the other thing is that most physicians are Type A personalities. Just by the nature of who they are, they can create stress even if they don't open their mouths."
Conflict isn't always about screaming matches at the front desk.
"Sometimes one employee could be angry with another and could be withholding information, being quiet, not giving them everything they need, forgetting to give important data and messages," Levine says. "Anger. Talking behind the other employee's back. Sarcasm. Those are the warning signs that something needs to be handled. Usually it is underneath the surface and you have to look for it because it can become a shouting match."
Paula M. Comm, a practice administrator at PRA Behavioral LLC, serving the northwestern suburbs of Chicago, says the head psychiatrist at the practice has a zero tolerance policy toward workplace conflict. "He hates conflict, and he really practices what he preaches," Comm says. "Especially in a psychiatric practice, you don't want someone coming to the window and feeling the tensions that are going on within the office because it's so apparent."
Comm says she is aggressive in sniffing out workplace tension. And one of the best ways to do it, she says, is to get out of your office and stand in the hall and listen.
"I go up there and just stand. I can get a feel for what is going on immediately. I can tell by the tone, by the attitude. I have an office manager beneath me who isn't attuned," Comm says. "So, I will go in and stand up there and go to her office and say, 'Do you know that it's tense up there?' And she will say 'what do you mean?' "
Levine says one major reason for conflict is personality differences. "We have different beliefs and different philosophies. We have different stories and programs based on our past experience," she says. "Even though I understand my job is to do X, I am still a human being bringing my own personal stuff into the workplace. I'm not going to like everybody else's personality and I may not understand exactly what I need to be doing or there might not be the same communication style between a couple of employees."
Levine says personality profiling plays a prominent role when she coaches employees at physician offices.
"Let's say I find out somebody is a director type. They give quick information; they don't like to converse. If I understand that person's style, I can use behavioral flexibility and talk to them in that way," she says. "If someone is more of a relater, they like to socialize, chit-chat. Then again, we teach how to be more behaviorally flexible in that area."
Levine says many of the employees she coaches are surprised to learn of their personality type, but their coworkers aren't.
"I was with a group last month and one person came out to be a director. The rest of the group was all saying 'Yup!' and the person said 'I didn't think I was like that.' Then as we went through specific examples of how a director behaves, she said 'Yes, that is me.' "
Levine says the way to reduce physician office conflict is not to hire the same types of people, but to make sure each employee understands one another's personality traits.
"We need a combination of personalities in the office. It's better to have all different personalities. If you've got a patient who needs TLC, get the relater our there, not the director," she says. "If you understand how your coworkers function in the world, you can have some behavioral flexibility toward them and some more understanding of who they are."
Levine says there are "three common denominators" in conflict resolution that facilitate that flexibility.
"First, be more understanding of how other people react. Second, increase group cohesion and mutual 'Let's work together to figure out the conflict.' Third, use your improved self-knowledge to understand what happens to you when you feel conflict," she says.
When employees come to her with a complaint about a coworker, Comm says she encourages them to meet face-to-face to constructively to resolve the problem.
"The worst thing is one employee complaining to me about another employee. When I confront that employee, that employee will say 'Why didn't she just tell me in the first place? Why did she have to go to you?' It's kind of like 'I'm telling Mom!' "
"The first response out of me is 'Have you spoken with her directly?' Because that is how you develop healthy relations. You talk to each other directly, because sometimes instant messaging can be misinterpreted," Comm says.
The Ohio House of Representatives is considering a bill that would mandate prison time for people convicted of felony assault against on-duty nurses.
The bill, HB 450, sponsored by Democratic State Reps. Linda S. Bolon of Columbiana, and Denise Driehaus of Cincinnati, would treat a physical assault on a nurse—or her unborn child—the same as an assault on school employees, police, fire, and EMS workers, which under Ohio law is a fourth-degree felony with a mandatory one-year prison sentence.
The proposed law would apply when the victim is an on-duty registered nurse or a licensed practical nurse, who the attacker knows is working as a licensed medical professional.
"I want to do everything in my power to not only protect these hard-working men and women as they do their jobs, but also to aid this vital profession in its efforts to recruit the next generation of nurses," Driehaus said in a media release.
The bill was introduced on Feb. 11 and has yet to be assigned to committee. A fiscal note that would identify any financial impact to the state has not been published.
The Ohio Nurses Association says HB 450 recognizes that violent acts against nurses in the workplace occur more frequently than in any other profession.
"ONA has long advocated for legislation to protect nurses from violence in the workplace, and we are proud to support House Bill 450 as a key part of ONA's overall workplace violence prevention initiative," said Elise Geig, ONA director of Health Policy. Geig says the bill has received bipartisan support from across the state.
BayCare Health System this week opened a new $225 million hospital in suburban Lutz, just north of Tampa. St. Joseph's North is the first full-service hospital built in the Tampa Bay area in more than 30 years.
The 350,000-square-foot, three-story hospital features 108 private beds, 32 of which are for outpatient observation, and 76 of which are for inpatient care. The "all-digital" hospital offers emergency care, surgical services, imaging and diagnostic facilities, ICU, and a family-centered environment.
The full-service Emergency Department at St. Joseph's Hospital-North includes 30 private rooms for adult and pediatric patients. A fast-track area expedites treatment for minor emergencies.
Many of the private suites include large HDTVs, full bathrooms, and accommodations for an overnight guest. Room service provides made-to-order meals.
"Our family-centered care philosophy allows relatives and visitors to be collaborators in patient care," said Paula McGuiness, COO for St. Joseph's Hospital-North. "By incorporating the family, everyone is working together to meet the needs of the patient."
Evidence-based design include an identical floor plan to improve efficiency; workflow designs to ensure that medication, supplies, and meals deliveries keep caregivers close to patients; and noise reduction features, such as carpeted hallways, noise-absorbing tiles and glass sound barriers.
St. Joseph's North is LEED-registered by the U.S. Green Building Council, and the building is designed to achieve green building certification. The building is made of materials that support energy conservation and clean air with low chemical emissions and recycled content.
Austin, TX-based St. David's HealthCare announced today that it will acquire the 58-bed Heart Hospital of Austin from MedCath Corp.
Financial terms of the deal were not disclosed.
"This facility acquisition will complement the already exceptional cardiovascular programs currently operating throughout St. David's HealthCare," said Jon M. Foster, president/CEO of St. David's HealthCare, in a media release. "One of the clinical areas St. David's HealthCare has continued to develop regionally is our cardiovascular service, which is strong thanks to the outstanding care provided by our St. David's HealthCare-affiliated physicians and staff."
The acquisition will be finalized after the regulatory approval process.
St. David's HealthCare operates seven hospitals in the Austin area, and MedCath is a 10-hospital health system based in Charlotte, NC.
The Jan. 12 earthquake that flattened much of Port au Prince, Haiti, and killed at least 230,000 people is providing valuable lessons for disaster preparedness and response on an almost unimaginable scale, says Scripps Health CEO/President Chris Van Gorder.
"There were two reasons why we went down there," says Van Gorder, who recently returned from his second trip to the stricken nation since the earthquake. "The first was humanitarian. The second was the learning. I am passionate about disaster planning and I don't believe the time to learn how to function in a disaster is when the disaster occurs."
Van Gorder concedes that it's doubtful that the United States will experience a natural disaster of similar magnitude because of building codes, infrastructure, engineering, and planning. The Haitian earthquake and the 1989 earthquake that struck the San Francisco Bay area both measured around 7.0 on the Richter Scale. The San Francisco quake claimed 63 lives. Even Hurricane Katrina, with more than 1,800 fatalities, pales in comparison to the death toll in Haiti.
Regardless, Van Gorder says providing care in the most challenging of environments is giving U.S. healthcare professionals valuable experience that can't be replicated by disaster training drills.
"We saw the injuries that would occur in an earthquake—major extremity injuries, major crush injuries, amputations, spinal cord injuries, pressure ulcers caused by people being underground and in the same position for extended periods of time," Van Gorder says.
The Scripps response team and a University of Maryland medical team worked in the remains of the Hospital St. Francois de Sales. It was grim, desperate work under bad conditions.
"Half the hospital collapsed, a four-story building which was their pediatric unit. The estimate was somewhere between 50 and 200 bodies were still entombed in the building," Van Gorder says. "We went into some areas of the hospital that hadn't collapsed, but were adjacent to the building and the smell was atrocious. Our CMO said he almost threw up, and he has been dealing with trauma his entire career."
Even in those hellish conditions, Van Gorder says he was inspired by the extraordinary flexibility and creativity of doctors and nurses.
"They created as sterile an environment as possible without the tools we have here. Our scrub sink was a bucket outside. We saw a rip saw that was being sterilized for amputations. Fortunately we didn't have to use it."
"We were doing our anesthesia on the first trip with ketamine. There was no general anesthesia. There was no intubating the patients during surgery," he says. "A nurse anesthetist gave them a shot and disappeared. I was responsible for monitoring the patients' vitals while the surgeon did surgery and I was a scrub nurse. It wasn't Civil War medicine, but it was more like World War I medicine."
When the Scripps team returned to Haiti with more medical supplies, Van Gorder says they could administer pain medications and general anesthesia.
"Instead of going directly to amputations, we were trying to save limbs," he says. "But we had one woman who died of pneumonia and congestive heart failure. There was no technology there to save her. She died outside under a tent. It was the best we could do under the circumstances."
Van Gorder says the road to recovery for Haiti will be long. Non-governmental organizations that are trying to provide care and other assistance must understand that the Haitian government has essentially ceased to exist.
"The Health Ministry completely collapsed with many of the leaders of healthcare in Haiti killed within the building. The Supreme Court was killed in session. The palace has been destroyed," Van Gorder says.
"The question is what happens from here? It's a poor country that imports everything and exports little if anything. They had a hard time feeding and educating their population before this. Look at the destruction, both in the public and private infrastructure, and you wonder where the money is going to come from to rebuild. I often wonder how long countries and hospitals will have the appetite to continue to work in Haiti. It's not month, we are talking years before they can recover."
The White House hinted that President Obama might post his own health reform bill on the Internet before the bipartisan healthcare summit he is planning for next week, the New York Times reports. Obama has announced the health summit to try breathe life back into the legislation and has promised to put the Democrats' bill online before the session. During a news conference, President Obama said he envisioned posting a merged House-Senate bill that would address his goals of controlling costs and expanding coverage, the Times reports.
An early morning fight at a roadhouse on Presidents Day spilled into the emergency department at Scotland Memorial Hospital in Laurinburg, NC, and ended in a shooting that left a patient in critical condition, his alleged assailant in jail, and the hospital in lockdown.
Scotland Memorial officials issued a statement detailing the 3 a.m. shooting on Monday morning, which remains under investigation by Laurinburg police.
"An individual, stating he was a patient's brother, asked to be let into the Emergency Center to visit his brother. The patient was being treated for a facial laceration that he stated he received as an innocent bystander of a fight that broke out between others. He essentially told the police the same story," the hospital statement read.
"The suspected shooter, upon entering into the patient's room shot him several times and then left the room, wandering around the Emergency Center, looking for an exit, finally exiting from the X-ray area."
"The Scotland Memorial Hospital Emergency Center staff initially took cover, then immediately called 911 and the nursing supervisor once the suspect left their area. The supervisor called the hospital units, alerting them—all units secured themselves and their patients. EC staff quickly returned to their patient care duties, including caring for the injured patient and later, the suspect himself. Local law enforcement responded quickly and captured the suspect on the hospital grounds," the statement read.
The hospital was put into lockdown for several hours following the incident. No visitors were allowed in or out of the facility until 7 a.m., but security staff used wands to check Emergency Center visitors, according to Scotland Memorial.
Scotland Memorial CEO/President Greg Wood said that the wounded patient suffered critical injuries, and has been removed from the hospital.
"We have never experienced anything like this in our hospital before," Wood said in a media release. "The safety of our patients, visitors, and staff is of paramount importance to us and we have extensive security measures in place to minimize the likelihood of such a horrific incident as this. Staff is receiving stress debriefing and we will conduct a thorough review of our policies to see how to strengthen our security even more. Our staff responded with the professionalism expected of them, ensuring that their co-workers and the other patients were unharmed."
Calls to the Laurinburg Police Department were not immediately returned. However, The Fayetteville (NC) Observer reported that police identified the shooting victim as Domario Covington, and that he suffered multiple gunshot wounds to the chest. The alleged gunman was identified as Wayne "Wolf" Simmons, 49. Police told the newspaper the shooting stemmed from an incident at a nightclub in nearby McColl, SC.
The call by Florida's private health insurance plans to expand Medicaid managed care while eliminating fee-for-service programs and the state's MediPass program is meeting resistance from healthcare providers.
"We don't think that the single approach that the health plans put forward is the one thing that Florida should do," says Bruce J. Rueben, president of the Florida Hospital Association. "Rather, there should be multiple numbers of approaches that are more directly suited to the population centers and the communities that need to be served."
Rueben says HMOs don't work well in rural areas with sparse populations and few services. "In urban areas, there are enough primary care doctors and specialists, there is the full continuum of care from acute-care services through emergency care services all the way through long-term care," he says.
Florida is staring at an estimated $3 billion shortfall for fiscal 2010-2011. State lawmakers have asked healthcare stakeholders for ideas to contain runaway costs for the $17.9 billion Medicaid program, the fourth-largest Medicaid program in the nation, which grew by 11% last year and consumes about 26% of the state's budget.
There were 17 Medicaid HMOs operating in 35 Florida counties last year. Thirty-one counties had no HMOs, and 27 counties had no managed care presence. More than 1.1 million of Florida Medicaid's 2.7 million eligible beneficiaries are now in HMOs. About 35% of beneficiaries are in fee-for-service programs, and 17% of beneficiaries, are in the Medipass primary care case management program, according to the state Agency for Health Care Administration.
Michael W. Garner, president/CEO of the Florida Association of Health Plans, Inc., says that transitioning the remaining beneficiaries into managed care plans could save $111 million over the next two years.
"We have been arguing that we need to move away from fee-for-service to a managed care system, much like a large employer will bring in an administrator to take over the management of their healthcare insurance and/or purchase insurance and transfer the risk to someone," Garner says. "We say give it to the health plans that are experts in managing risk and let us deal with it."
"We believe we bring improved access. We believe we can demonstrate quality and accountability better, and cost savings. We believe we are an effective mechanism for helping to control potential fraud and abuse in the Medicaid program," he says.
Jeff Scott, general counsel for the Florida Medical Association, says the health plans want the state to reduce provider payments by 10% to those who won't switch to managed care.
"Obviously, they want to eliminate fee-for-service because they want the entire Medicaid market to themselves," Scott says. "If you look at their proposal, what they've asked for is that in areas where they have a hard time negotiating a price that would allow them to make money off of being the Medicaid provider, they want the state to intervene and tell the hospitals and providers to negotiate in good faith."
Scott adds that insurers' definition of "good faith" is the HMO demanding reduced reimbursements without much provider input and the state going along with the cuts.
"That is the antithesis of a free market system. It's bizarre how they can make that recommendation with a straight face," says Scott.
Rueben says that—rather than giving tax dollars to out-of-state insurance companies—the state should continue to support local provider service networks that he says are cost-effective, and popular with beneficiaries.
"If you can do it here in Florida and keep those dollars in Florida, it is better than doing this for commercial HMOs that take their profits out of Florida," Rueben says. "Hospitals and doctors have made a commitment to live and work in Florida and serve Florida patients. These HMOs, if the picture is less than rosy, they're out of here."
Garner says the kind of Medicaid savings needed to help resolve the budget crisis can only be generated by eliminating fee-for-service payments. "The core of the problem is the way the fee-for-service system functions, which is to reward payment for utilization. The more you use the more you get paid," he says.
More than half of neurosurgeons in a national survey say they will cut services and time spent with Medicare patients if Congress doesn't act to permanently fix the sustainable growth rate formula, and prevent the 21.5% reimbursement cuts that are scheduled to go into effect on March 1.
The online survey also found that nearly 40% of the of 678 neurosurgeons who responded said they would decrease the number of Medicare patients they see, and more than 18% said they would no longer take new Medicare patients.
"These results really do paint a bleak path we are going down. Many neurosurgeons in our survey indicated that if Medicare payments continue to decline, they would stop providing certain services, reduce staff, defer purchase of new medical equipment, reduce time spent with Medicare patients, and begin referring complex cases elsewhere," said Troy M. Tippett, MD, president of the American Association of Neurosurgical Surgeons, one of three neurosurgical associations that sponsored of the survey. "It is crucial that Congress pass legislation immediately to address the decline in Medicare payments so that we can alter this course."
Tippett said neurosurgeons do not support the annual temporary "doctor's fix" that will only make it more costly to repeal the SGR in the future.
The survey found that neurosurgeons have seen changes in Medicare that have made it less patient friendly in the past five years. Most notably:
It has gotten harder to refer patients to certain medical and surgical specialists (67.2%).
More physicians are referring Medicare patients with complex problems to other doctors (64.8%).
Medicare patients now have to travel further to get needed care (63.7%).
Neurosurgeons are reducing the number of Medicare patients in their practice because of low reimbursement (59.2%).
The average waiting time for a patient appointment is 24.1 days for new patients and 19.5 days for established patients.
Neurosurgeons who limit the number of Medicare appointment slots do so through the scheduling process (42%), by limiting the overall number of Medicare patients they treat (35%), or by selecting patients based on their geographic location (10%).
Survey results also show that not all U.S. geographic locations are alike. Medicare patients in the Southwest face more difficulties in finding neurosurgeons. When compared to the national average, the Northwest and Northeast quadrants appear to be a bit more stable.
The survey was conducted by Perception Solutions in September, and has a 5% margin of error. The survey was sponsored by the AANS, the Congress of Neurological Surgeons, and the Council of State Neurosurgical Societies, which combined represent about 7,600 neurosurgeons.